Real Transformation at the Cathedral of St. Peter in Belleville, Illinois

/ November 6, 2025

by Rob Mueller

Fr. Godfrey Mullen
Editor’s Note: Since this success story was originally published in November 2025, Fr. Godfrey Mullen, OSB, has been appointed and ordained Bishop of Belleville. We are grateful for Bishop Godfrey’s continued partnership with Catholic Stewardship Consultants and look forward to seeing the principles of stewardship continue to bear fruit throughout the Diocese of Belleville.

When Fr. Godfrey Mullen, OSB, arrived at the Cathedral of St. Peter, he encountered a parish struggling with financial issues and low parishioner engagement. Most ministries relied on parish staff, Mass attendance was stagnant, and the parish’s potential went untapped. However, with the right approach to stewardship, he turned it around.

“The CSC approach to stewardship is truly rooted in spirituality,” Fr. Godfrey says. “It’s not a fundraising program. It’s a conversion process.”

A New Culture Rooted in Gratitude and Mission

With the help of Catholic Stewardship Consultants (CSC), Fr. Godfrey launched a Stewardship Renewal that changed everything. He developed a comprehensive annual plan designed to enhance their communication, education, and evangelization efforts through monthly parish newsletters, engaging social media posts, and a stewardship renewal.

The Cathedral embraced stewardship across all dimensions of parish life:

  • Communication: High-quality newsletters and clear messaging engaged parishioners.
  • Stewardship of Time through Prayer: Parishioners learned to see prayer as a meaningful gift. “With prayer as a cornerstone of the Christian life, that connection made a big difference,” Fr. Godfrey notes.
  • Discipleship: Homilies emphasized stewardship as a way to live out faith.
  • Hospitality and Ministry Growth: Encouraging openness to new ministries energized parish involvement.

“The quality of the newsletters has been a major change in each parish I’ve served,” Fr. Godfrey says. “People saw themselves in those stories. It built a culture of gratitude and participation.”

These initiatives fostered a culture where stewardship became integral to parish life. Once this stewardship formation took root, Fr. Godfrey invited his parishioners to make commitments in prayer, ministry involvement, and financial giving through an annual stewardship renewal.

The Results: Renewed Spirit and Measurable Growth

The transformation is measurable, and the results were extraordinary. Through the commitments collected in the stewardship renewals, Fr. Godfrey was able to quantify the spiritual, practical, and financial impact of his stewardship efforts. Parishioner engagement soared as the number of parishioners actively participating in ministries grew significantly. Mass attendance, participation in Confession and Adoration, and adult faith formation offerings all rose. And the Sunday offertory increased dramatically.

“The atmosphere of the parish has become more positive, joyful, communal,” Fr. Godfrey explains. “With more volunteers engaged, more is happening throughout the parish. We have the money to pay our bills. And we have hope for good things to come.”

“Trusting that opening the door — hospitality — to new ministries and ideas in the parish is the way it will grow has also made a significant difference,” he adds.

Beyond Programs — A Way of Life

Stewardship has fostered a joyful, communal parish culture. Parishioners are more engaged in prayer, including Advent and Lenten practices. Increased volunteer involvement has expanded ministries, while financial stability allows the parish to meet its obligations confidently.

The Cathedral of St. Peter is preparing for continued growth, including a capital campaign and expanded leadership structures. CSC’s ongoing support ensures that the parish can continue modeling stewardship as a way of life.

Fr. Godfrey emphasizes, “The more intangible change is noticeable participation at Mass, more interest in other prayer opportunities, and a view of what we can do instead of what we can’t.”

Take the Next Step Toward Stewardship Renewal

If you’ve ever wondered how to awaken stewardship in your parish — to move beyond maintenance and into mission — we invite you to take the next step.

Let’s talk about how your parish can experience this kind of renewal.

We’ll listen to what your parish is already doing, share insights from our nearly 30 years of developing stewardship, and offer practical tips you can immediately implement to foster a culture of stewardship.

REVITALIZE YOUR PARISH:
CLICK HERE TO SCHEDULE YOUR FREE STRATEGY TRAINING SESSION

(15 minutes — free, practical, and immediately applicable)